Tasted 65 Aussie Easter Chocolates and Ranked the Best to Worst

Australian Easter Chocolate Taste Test: The Best and Worst of the Season

With Easter just around the corner, the hunt for the perfect chocolate has begun. But with so many options on the shelves, how do you know which one to choose? To help you make an informed decision, a team of food experts took on the challenge of tasting 65 different Easter chocolates from various supermarkets and gourmet brands.

The results were surprising, with some classic choices coming out on top and others leaving tasters divided. Here’s a detailed look at the best and worst Easter chocolates in Australia based on taste, texture, and overall Easter festivity.

Key Takeaways

• A team of food experts, including senior food editor Sarah Murphy, tested 65 Easter chocolates from Woolworths, ALDI, Coles, and gourmet brands.
• The chocolates were evaluated on three main criteria: taste, texture, and how festive they felt.
• The most divisive chocolate was the KitKat Hot Cross Bun Chocolate, which scored the lowest in the test.
• The team also previously reviewed all available hot cross buns, with some unexpected results.

Brands Tested

The team sampled chocolates from a variety of well-known brands, including:

Australian supermarket brands

– Cadbury

– Nestle (Milkybar and KitKat)

– ALDI Dairy Fine

– Darrell Lea

– Lindt

– Ferrero Rocher

– Kinder

Gourmet brands

– Koko Black

– Haigh’s Chocolates

Over two afternoons, the team tasted each chocolate, assessing its flavor, texture, and packaging. The entire office participated, with Sarah Murphy leading the judging process. Each chocolate received a score out of 10, along with anonymous feedback.

The Overall Winner

The winner of the taste test was Cadbury Dairy Milk Hollow Easter Eggs, scoring an impressive 9.6/10. Tasters described it as the “ultimate Easter egg,” with many recalling childhood memories of egg hunts and Easter morning gifts. The eggs were smooth, easy to eat, and offered the perfect balance of chocolate without feeling too indulgent.

What made this result surprising was that it wasn’t a high-end gourmet chocolate but a classic supermarket choice. For many Australians, nostalgia and convenience are key factors when choosing Easter chocolates.

Top 10 Easter Chocolates

After Cadbury, several other chocolates made the top 10 list, showcasing a mix of premium and value-for-money options.

01. Cadbury Dairy Milk Hollow Eggs – 9.6/10

Hollow eggs took the crown in our taste test, and honestly, no one saw that coming. These eggs are perfect for guests, kids, and Easter egg hunts. The ombre wrappers add a festive touch, making them a standout choice.

Price: $12, currently on sale for $6.90 at Woolworths!

Available at: Woolworths, Coles, Big W

02. Darrell Lea Rocklea Road with Speckled Eggs – 7.8/10

For those looking for great value, Darrell Lea’s speckled eggs are a top pick. Sweet but not too rich, they offer excellent value for money at $9 during sales.

Price: $18, currently on sale for $9 at Big W.

Available at: Darrell Lea, Woolworths, Coles, Big W

03. Haigh’s Milk Speckles Half Egg – 9.3/10

Haigh’s Chocolates made a strong showing in the top 10. Their milk speckles are a favorite among Australians, and the half egg is ideal for Easter. Though pricier, it’s perfect for premium gifts.

Price: $27.50

Available at: Haigh’s Chocolates

04. Haigh’s Milk Chocolate Egg – 9.2/10

This egg comes in various sizes, from 50g to 1kg. It’s smooth, creamy, and highly rated by tasters. Megan Osborne, an editor, recommends the 500g size for the best price per 100g.

Price: from $8.50

Available at: Haigh’s Chocolates

05. Ferrero Rocher Hazelnut Eggs – 9/10

These chocolate wafer eggs with hazelnut filling were described as “DELIGHTFUL” and “almost too addictive.” They’re a step up from standard supermarket eggs.

Price: $9

Available at: Ferrero Online, Woolworths, Coles, Big W

06. Cadbury Turkish Delight Chocolate Easter Eggs – 8.8/10

Turkish Delight was the standout among Cadbury’s filled eggs. It’s not too sweet, has a good balance of chocolate, and brings back nostalgic memories.

Price: $5.50

Available at: Woolworths, Coles, Big W

07. Ferrero Rocher Chocolate Gift Box – 8.8/10

Though not Easter-themed, this gift box is a go-to for fancy Easter gifts. Its rich gold packaging and hazelnut center make it a popular choice.

Price: $32, currently 50% off at Woolworths.

Available at: Ferrero Online, Woolworths, Coles

08. Cadbury Mini Eggs – 8.7/10

These mini eggs are a hit for their cute appearance and delicious crunch. Many tasters found them unbeatable for a quick snack.

Price: $7.50

Available at: Coles, Woolworths, Amazon

09. Lindt Gold Hazelnut Easter Bunny – 8.6/10

As the only Easter bunny in the top 10, this Lindt bunny offers a perfect balance of nutty flavor and smooth chocolate.

Price: $12

Available at: Lindt, Woolworths, Coles, Myer, Kmart

10. Ferrero Rocher Cocoa Easter Eggs – 8.6/10

These dark chocolate eggs are a unique addition to the top 10. Their crispy shell and ganache-like filling make them rich yet not overly sweet.

Price: $9.30

Available at: Ferrero Online, Woolworths, Coles

How We Tested

The team conducted an open-packaging taste test, keeping the packaging next to each product to fairly assess the level of Easter festivity. Each participant rated the chocolates on a scale of 10, with scores based on taste, texture, and overall theme.

Who Was Involved?

The entire Better Homes & Gardens team and wider office were involved in the tasting. With boxes of eggs, bunnies, and gift boxes, sharing was essential during the test.

What to Read Next

• [Product reviews] Australia’s top supermarket hot cross bun revealed: 23 tested, one clear winner
• [Product reviews] We tried Woolworths’ viral $10 Cinnabon cake – here’s our honest verdict
• [Product reviews] We tried 30+ luxury chocolates – these are the only ones worth gifting this Valentine’s Day
• [Tips & How-to] We tried Kmart’s $4 bag sealer, and “it shouldn’t be this hard”
• [Product reviews] 20 Aussies tried Christmas mince pies from Woolworths, Coles, Aldi & IGA – and there was one clear winner
• [Product reviews] We tried Christmas cakes from Woolies, Coles and ALDI and one literally “tastes like fridge”